Character Recommendations Based on Will Schuester

Andie Walsh Pretty in Pink

If the awesome Andie is from the wrong side of the tracks, we don't want to be right

Lily Aldrin How I Met Your Mother

A flaky but supportive kindergarten teacher and painter

Ted Mosby How I Met Your Mother

Hopelessly romantic architect in search of someone to be the mother of his children

Dorothy Gale The Wizard of Oz

A down-home Kansas girl in a bizarre fantasy land

Juliet Capulet Romeo & Juliet

There's only one man for her, no matter what her family says

Derek Morgan Criminal Minds

A guy you want to have your back when it counts most

Gabriella Montez High School Musical

She's smart, a little shy, and a darling of the stage

Merry Brandybuck The Lord of the Rings

A troublemaking hobbit with a brave streak that some might call foolhardy

Donna Carmichael Mamma Mia!

Free-spirited single mom and gracefully aging hippie

Matt Flamhaff 13 Going on 30

He's not too concerned about being part of the popular crowd. Too bad his best friend is