Because you like Eli in Let the Right One In
Phoebe Halliwell is a bestselling author and martial arts master with power of premonitions. See them in Charmed.
Although Morrigan knows every kind of magic there is, friendship is an untested area for her. See them in Dragon Age Series.
Galina Reznikov is the head chef of prison, cooking up meals as well as storms on anyone who dares to cross her; even the guards are terrified of her. See them in Orange Is The New Black.
Rupert Giles is a librarian on the outside, fearless evil-fighter on the inside. See them in Buffy the Vampire Slayer.
Sometimes being a supportive girlfriend like Ophelia doesn't work out too well. See them in Hamlet.
Sharply perceptive and stubbornly principled, Jane Eyre might not have a very loud voice, but she knows when and how to use it. See them in Jane Eyre.
Joe West is overprotective and secretive when his children are involved. See them in DC Extended Universe.
Although Jareth seems like he's just a harmless romantic, his powers make him a formidable foe. See them in Labyrinth.