Character Recommendations Based on Sarah Manning
Amethyst Steven Universe

Reckless, outgoing, and always ready for fun
Dave Strider Homestuck

An ironic hipster with a healthy dose of self-deprecation, Dave strives to be cool at all costs
Satsuki Kiryuin Kill la Kill

"Ask not the sparrow how the eagle soars!"
Moe Szyslak The Simpsons

Crabby owner of the grimiest bar in Springfield
C.C. Code Geass

For somebody who won’t answer questions, the enigmatic C.C. sure asks a lot of them
Elena Gilbert The Vampire Diaries

The quintessential girl-next-door who gets involved with the new "boy" at school
Sabrina Spellman Chilling Adventures of Sabrina

Powerful, young, and ambitious witch who gets everything she wants
El Diablo Suicide Squad

El Diablo's fiery temper produces actual fire
Donna Carmichael Mamma Mia!

Free-spirited single mom and gracefully aging hippie
Mako Mankanshoku Kill la Kill

"Please wear pajamas like everyone else when you sleep!"