Because you like Dante Alighieri in Dante's Inferno
Christine Daae has been secretely taking lessons from a phantom musician. It sounded less creepy in her head. See them in The Phantom of the Opera.
The adventurous daughter of Port Royal's governor, Elizabeth Swann would rather conspire with pirates than sit pretty in her corset. See them in Pirates of the Caribbean: the Curse of the Black Pearl.
Introspective Theodore Twombly would rather observe life than participate in it. See them in Her.
Anna Karenina doesn't want to be a respectable woman any more. She thinks respect was invented to cover the empty place where love should be. See them in Anna Karenina.
Abbi Abrams is the ultimate wingwoman because she wants nothing more than to have a good time for its own sake. See them in Broad City.
Tina Cohen-Chang is a shy loner who becomes a fierce performer on stage. See them in Glee.
Egon Spengler prefers collecting spores, molds, and fungus to interacting with people. See them in Ghostbusters.
The only constant in Night Vale is Cecil's hypnotic voice. See them in Welcome to Night Vale.
Betty Cooper seems like a sweet girl, but she also has a dark side and can go beyond what's safe or sane. See them in Archie Comics.
Raised to happily follow the rules, Cassia might actually be more rebellious than she thinks she is. See them in Matched .