Character Recommendations Based on Aunt Lydia

Rupert Giles Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Librarian on the outside, fearless evil-fighter on the inside

Burton Guster Psych

A level-headed investigator with a "Super Sniffer" nose

Terry Jeffords Brooklyn Nine-Nine

Terry (and his muscles) may look ferocious, but inside he's just a caring mama hen

Mrs. Hudson Sherlock

There's more to this sweet, caring landlady than meets the eye

Shuya Nanahara Battle Royale

Though cynical about the world, Shuya is caring and protective towards his friends

John Dorian Scrubs

As a doctor-in-training, JD's head should be in the game. But most of the time, it's in the clouds

Effie Trinket The Hunger Games

Utterly enamored with all things fashion, make-up, and style

Mary Margaret Blanchard Once Upon a Time

This meek schoolteacher can't remember her past as a spirited, swashbuckling Snow White

Selina Meyer Veep

Being Vice President certainly isn't enough to satisfy Selina's ego, but she'll deal with it. For now

Tim Riggins Friday Night Lights (TV)

Brooding halfback who has cornered Dillon's market for "troubled bad boy"