Character Recommendations Based on Nick Carraway

Jess Mariano Gilmore Girls

Some might call him mysterious. Others just call him moody

The Phantom The Phantom of the Opera

Madman, victim, murderer, or artist? No one knows the man behind the mask

Effy Stonem Skins

"Sometimes I think I was born backwards. You know, come out my mum the wrong way."

Blaine Anderson Glee

A put-together prep school boy with the voice of an angel

Amethyst Steven Universe

Reckless, outgoing, and always ready for fun

Arwen The Lord of the Rings

Headstrong, persuasive, and confident, Arwen will only do what she feels is right

Chidi Anagonye The Good Place

Ethical but anxious, Chidi approaches life like a problem to be solved

Samwise Gamgee The Lord of the Rings

The most loyal gardener – and perhaps the most loyal being, period – in all of Middle Earth

Bilbo Baggins The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey

A bumbling hobbit caught up in a big adventure

Squidward Tentacles SpongeBob SquarePants

Pretentious clarinet player in search of peace and quiet