Character Recommendations Based on Marge Gunderson

Captain Hook Once Upon a Time

A roguish pirate who isn't quite as villainous as he pretends to be

Dave Strider Homestuck

An ironic hipster with a healthy dose of self-deprecation, Dave strives to be cool at all costs

Cassie Sullivan The 5th Wave

Resilient, resourceful, and not quite as brave as she pretends to be

Spencer Reid Criminal Minds

His super-smarts helps catch killers, his social awkwardness endears co-workers

Jack Harkness Doctor Who

A dedicated hedonist who appreciates raunchy stories, stiff drinks, and excellent bottoms

Cassia Maria Reyes Matched

Raised to happily follow the rules, Cassia might actually be more rebellious than she thinks she is

Alison DiLaurentis Pretty Little Liars

Queen bee who traffics in secrets without giving away any of her own

Will Herondale Clockwork Angel

An arrogant, emotionally distant bad boy with a secret

Crowley Supernatural

A really bad guy, albeit with a good sense of humor

Emily Fields Pretty Little Liars

Though athletic and popular, the sensitive Emily's heart is frequently broken