Character Recommendations Based on Hurley Reyes

Merry Brandybuck The Lord of the Rings

A troublemaking hobbit with a brave streak that some might call foolhardy

Lily Aldrin How I Met Your Mother

A flaky but supportive kindergarten teacher and painter

Mrs. Hudson Sherlock

There's more to this sweet, caring landlady than meets the eye

Pippin Took The Lord of the Rings

Point the fun-loving Pippin towards second breakfast and he's one happy hobbit

Marshall Eriksen How I Met Your Mother

A lawyer in love with his fiancée, his friends, and enjoying life

Martha Jones Doctor Who

A compassionate medical student who has found a Doctor she can really look up to

Terry Jeffords Brooklyn Nine-Nine

Terry (and his muscles) may look ferocious, but inside he's just a caring mama hen

Samwise Gamgee The Lord of the Rings

The most loyal gardener – and perhaps the most loyal being, period – in all of Middle Earth

Rupert Giles Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Librarian on the outside, fearless evil-fighter on the inside

Alex Vause Orange Is The New Black

Tattooed lady who's a softie under her tough shell